The Hungry Journalist

Tracking the slow death of old-school journalism

Penn State’s legal problems: Wow

with 2 comments

I watched the Outside the Lines report on Penn State’s arrest problems, and was blown away by how much trouble the football program has been in.

And I’ve been in the middle of a season in which a football program has had some jailhouse blues.

Last year, beginning in the summer months prior to the season, the Texas football team had more encounters with the law than I can count on one hand, including a couple of felonies. Like Penn State’s issues, there was an apartment assault involved. There was also one crazy dude who tried twice in one night to break into some cars.

I must admit that I drank the anti-burnt orange kool-aid during the entire season when it came to character issues with the team, which I was covering then. I was on high alert for arrests and accusations and kept my eye on the local blotters. I got a little too deep into it toward the very end, and I learned a lot of lessons from that season when it comes to what people find appropriate when covering athletes and crime.

But I cannot imagine being a reporter in State College.

And recalling my own experiences after watching the ESPN peice, which I enjoyed, I realize now how well UT handled everything.

Like the fact that, after a certain point, the arrests stopped. This means that the team, coaches and administration got a hold of the situation. They talked to the players and send a resounding message that seemed to work.

Get your shit together, or we will do that for you and throw it and you out of this university.

Penn State, on the other hand, had no such luck. From beer-bottle brawls to threats at knifepoint, the trouble just won’t stop for the program. It’s gone beyond bad press to a legitimate problem within the program.

It seemed last season that Texas was heading in the same direction.

But the reason Texas seemed to get stuff under control, in my opinion, stems from coach Mack Brown. I’m no Brown apologist. But when I saw him at the impromptu press conference put on to adress the team’s legal issues, I believed him when he said he’d been unable to sleep for a week.

It was obvious he cares about the integrity of the team, and that he recognized just how bad things were getting.

Penn State’s coach, Joe Paterno, took a very different approach. Though he forced his kids to clean up the stadium, which was very old school and sounded like a good idea, it was more show than solution.

And when approached by OTL, JoPa called it a “witch hunt.”

Stephen A. Smith called for Paterno’s job. I don’t agree with that, mostly because I have no right to think someone should have their ability to work taken way, but it seems to me that Paterno didn’t do his job with the OTL interview.

Blaming the media for pointing out a blatant problem like this is like being mad at a doctor for telling you smoking is dangerous to your health. OTL did a bad job in trying to say that Penn State started recruiting bad seeds, even if it’s true. I feel it was in Texas’ case, but trying to present that as fact in reporting is irresponsible.

But JoPa was out of line calling this a witch hunt. If he doesn’t start redirecting those emotions toward his wayward players, people will continue to call for his resignation.

And worst of all, his players might keep clogging up the State College blotters.

Written by RickyTreon

July 27, 2008 at 12:18 pm

2 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Ha. I really was a reporter in State College and I still often go back there to do Penn State stories, including a few on their legal troubles. It’s not so bad.

    I rarely covered sports, but I did attend one JoePa press conference. At that one, just like every other one, he showed a lot of contempt for the media. The OTL interview was absolutely par for the course. In fact, PSU is going to have a class for sports journalists based entirely on Paterno’s relationship with the media.

    I’ve also met Paterno in person outside of my role as a reporter, and he is an unbelievably charming, engaging guy.

    People always ask if Paterno has “lost his grip on the team,” and I always thought that wasn’t the right question. Incidents happen everywhere, and I’ve never seen a convincing case that the numbers OTL reported (which have long been reported on locally) can be better described as a trend or as a statistical fluke. I’m not saying it’s either one, but these things tend to be prematurely painted as a pattern, which suggests a common cause that no one can confirm.

    The real issue isn’t the amount of incidents, it’s the response to them. That’s where the local media has requested straight answers from Paterno, the athletic department, the school president and trustees. They haven’t come.

    bydanielvictor

    July 28, 2008 at 6:10 pm

  2. Daniel – Well what are the odds. I was disappointed that OTL tried to link the arrests to intentionally recruiting players with “character issues.” But there’s no doubt in my mind that JoPa is not treating this “situation” correctly, at least when it comes to talking with fans and media. I thought the AD or whoever the Penn State admin. was on OTL did a pretty good job answering the questions, though.

    Ricky

    July 28, 2008 at 7:08 pm


Leave a Reply